Itching to unbalance

What I am learning from this challenge is that symmetry is definitely a much less comfortable idea for me than asymmetry.  I think my decision to use courthouse steps as a starting point has been helpful, up to a point,  but really all I need to do now is just keep cutting strips and going round and round.  And where, I ask myself, is the fun in that?  

You would think, wouldn't you, that I would be grateful for a nice, simple, pretty solution but clearly not.  I love these fabrics,the mix of florals and stripes and plaid,  and the general feel of what I have so far but I am itching to start unbalancing things.  I'm not even sure that would be a good idea at this point, but still I want to meddle.  

I will try to think of a way to tinker that doesn't upset things too much.

50 shades of pink

*Edit: photo updated, scroll down to see

Thank you for all the feedback on my last couple of posts,

seems like lots of you are enjoying my 50 shades of pink

💕

 

- next batch of crumb blocks

- my focus fabric 

I've been busy making more crumb blocks this week for my present pink project, the 'predictable' quilt, {pattern from @sunspell, who encourages you to put your own spin on her design}. It's all made up with HSTs, with the interest lying in the random way the triangles are laid out, giving it a modern vibe.

And I thought I'd combine this project somehow with the recent AHIQ challenge. Kaja from sewslowly discussed our various preferences to working asymmetrically or symmetrically with our quilts. Her new challenge is to pick whichever of these is furthest from your comfort zone and see what you can do.

After some research, a few panic moments & a couple of chats online {thanks to both Susan & Julie}, I'm thinking my 'predictable' quilt could be leaning towards being an asymmetrical quilt - it's got that modern asymmetrical composition with the more traditional HST blocks. I'm also planning on adding an asymmetrical border on two sides, shifting the midpoint over to further achieve asymmetry.

Here's a few progress photos of how things are looking down on the 'design floor' . . .

- now this is looking more interesting and exciting!

{wink wink} Still don’t know if I’m on the right track for the challenge, 

but I'm trying not to overthink this too much.

And it's certainly predictably unpredictable!

* EDIT

Ever had a picture of a quilt in your mind, 

then as you proceed, you find it's just not happening how you imagined?

Well, after lots of faffing around and with only 4 more blocks to make,

this is finally coming together nicely and making me smile again! 

Love to hear your thoughts on which sort of quilt you prefer to make -

symmetrical? or asymmetrical? 

Linda from kokaquilts

a new challenge

 a new challenge : Asymmetrical v Symmetrical

Kaja from sewslowly recently discussed our various preferences to working asymmetrically or symmetrically with our quilts. Her new challenge for AHIQ is to pick whichever of these is furthest from your comfort zone and see what you can do.

I did a little research and to put things simply - "Something is symmetrical when it is the same on both sides. A shape has symmetry if a central dividing line (a mirror line) can be drawn on it, to show that both sides of the shape are exactly the same".

Hmm, well I think I tend to make more symmetrical looking quilts, 

here's a few that stand out to me...

More research was required to further define asymmetry for me because, while I have made a few quilts that were definitely more improv in style, where that cohesive balance took a bit of work, I can't say I've ever made an asymmetrical {modern} quilt as such. 

But what I did find were a few examples of asymmetrical balance within my own quilts. Here are a few quilts that I think have an asymmetrical composition of traditional patchwork blocks, like the New York Beauty, Flying Geese, Log Cabins, Rail Fence, etc.

And like Janie from crazyvictoriana I knew if I shared these you'd get all excited, share your quilts, and maybe join in the challenge too . . .

 

This first quilt was made from a selection of orphan blocks. I guess it's improv, as I didn't use a pattern nor did I have any idea how the finished quilt was going to look. 

Again, this feels like improv to me, no pattern, just an overwhelming desire to work with the colour "grey". The asymmetrical balance in this quilt could be viewed as chaotic or visually interesting & exciting, depending on your point of view!

 symmetrical arrangement of asymmetrical blocks ↑

AND 

↓ asymmetrical arrangement of symmetrical blocks, yes?

And finally, leftover low volume blocks put together improv style using the 'magic numbers' formula. I love an inconsistently balanced quilt.

I think I mostly have the asymmetrical/symmetrical labeled right, let me know what you think.
Asymmetry is one topic I do find interesting, and definitely The. Most. Challenging. So I'm off now to deal to my present pink project, my 'predictable' quilt - it's been giving me headaches but I feel very much like it could fit somehow into the asymmetrical section of Kaja's challenge!

wish me luck 🤞

Linda from kokaquilts

Pandemonium - Asymmetrical Work in Progress

This is where things stand for now . . . 

You can see how it happened using the links below

for the process posts on my blog:

July 14, 2021

July 12, 2021

July 9, 2021

Introductory post - July 5, 2021

As is so often true for me,

I'm as excited about designing the scrappy back

as I am about designing the quilt top (grin).

Quiltdivajulie

 

String Tulips Quilted, Bound, and Mailed

 Kaja prompt will be challenging for me since I strongly prefer symmetrical bed quilts. But before starting the new one, I wanted to finish the previous prompt. {Could there be a more symmetrical quilt than this?} It's served its purpose as a sample for the QAL. And friends of my son would like a baby quilt. It needed to be quilted... and bound,.. and signed... and washed... and mailed. All those small steps that weigh us down. Done and dusted.

String Tulip baby quilt 3

Since I didn't trim the fabric behind the tulips, it's pretty thick there making it difficult to quilt.  The decision was simply outlining near the major seam lines. The white background is stippled/doodled. Not terribly close together but there's only one start and stop in that section. {I hate burying lots of threads when I can avoid it.}  

String Tulip 3 stipple quilting detail

The ESS blocks are free-hand quilted in a zig zag design that moves easily from one to the other because nothing shows in all this busy-ness. 

String Tulip 3 zig zag quilting detail

The outer border is a free-hand loop. And it's done.

Three purple {approximately} half yard pieces sewn dark to light create a simply back. Not clever but an easy way to use up some leftovers that also adds more color. Because this quilt was so quiet... ;-)

String Tulip 3 quilt back

Thanks for playing along with the String Tulip QAL. 

Ann

Asymmetrical symetrical

Asymmetry is one of the possible characteristics of modern quilts as listed by the Modern Quilt Guild. I find it an interesting, and definitely challenging, topic.

Asymmetrical symmetrical I take to mean symmetrical blocks arranged asymmetrically, as opposed to the symmetrical arrangement of asymmetrical blocks. I have several to date. Click on the caption under each photo to go to the original post.

Rainbow bears is the least asymmetrical arrangement of the lot:

Rainbow Bears' Square Dance

 

 

 The blocks are identical in shape and the arrangement is barely asymmetrical.

In "Star light, Star dark" each rectangular block contains the same units, but the blocks are arranged differently within the grid. By turning the blocks the arrangement is somewhat asymmetrical, but because the blocks are rectangular they could only be turned through 180 degrees, while 90 would have given more variety.

Star Light, Star Dark

 

 Modern Maples is an asymmetrical arrangement of a totally symmetrical block.

Modern maples

 

On the other hand, "Over the Hills and Far Away" is one asymmetrical block.

Over the Hills and Far Away

While asymmetry creates a dynamic in a quilt, it would appear that too much can become chaos, and is aesthetically less pleasing. My wonky log cabin table runner, which I'm still hand-quilting, is not to everyone's taste, and is in fact considered not to be patchwork at all! (??) 

 

I could have trimmed the blocks to squares, added sashing to make them symmetrical and to make the grid more obvious, but I didn't. Would that have been more pleasing to the eye? Personally I think that would have been boring, but that's just my opinion, and I didn't try it. The aesthetic is always personal taste.

I am intrigued by this challenge and am looking forward to seeing what everyone else comes up with. I have several ideas, I just hope I have enough time to follow them through!

Keep safe and healthy, 

Happy sewing, 

Marly.

Symmetry (or Not) Challenge Response

I posted about my orphan block stash here.

Since then those blocks have not been quiet 

about remaining in their project box.

\

Once I had LUDIC clipped for webbing

leaving the design wall empty again,

I pulled out all of the orphans.

Hmmmmm . . . 

Almost immediately I removed the orange blocks

left behind after piecing the top for 

October's kitchen table quilt (Trick or Treat).

They have been passed along to another maker.

I also decided that I will NOT be using 

black and white prints as filler.

(I've been watching Agilejack and lots of her blog followers

making Frankenbags and thought Anne's b-w ideas 

might work with my stash of orphans)

Instead I have pulled out several unused 

2.5" strips and a few more pieces 

of quilt back trimmings.

This mixture definitely has possibilities.

Next step will be to measure the various blocks,

count the scrappy rectangles and misc. HSTs,

add in the extra HSTs from Ludic, and

play around with graph paper and layout ideas.

Clearly I will be focusing on the 

ASYMMETRICAL

aspect of the new Symmetry challenge.

I have named this project Pandemonium.

(meaning 'a wild uproar')

* * *

This post was previously shared on my blog,

but I'm also adding it here to enhance the

AHIQ conversation.

Quiltdivajulie